Custom Cakes

Let Cute Yummy Cakes at the Sugar Free Shack create a masterpiece for your next party. Whether you need a custom cake to “wow” your friends and light social media on fire, or a quick grab-and-go cake for a birthday party at home, our cake decorators have a number of options to fit your needs.

We offer both sugar and sugar free cake options.
Check out our galleries below for inspiration.

Daily Cakes

Stop in and pick up a ready to go cake!

The Sugar Free Shack always has an assortment of tasty, ready to go daily cakes for our customers to purchase and take home. Daily cakes are made fresh by our decorators every single day and are perfect for any gathering from an office party, a birthday party, or for an after-dinner dessert.

Daily cakes come in two sizes: a 6 inch and 8 inch round cake that feeds 10 to 12 people and 20 to 24 people. The cakes come in a various assortment of flavors from vanilla, chocolate, red velvet to carrot. Give us a call or stop by to see what flavors are being sold.

Daily Cakes Gallery

Custom Cakes

Let us make a show-stopping work of art for your next event!

Whether is a birthday party, wedding, anniversary, or company event, we understand that a huge attention-grabbing cake can help make your party a truly memorable event. Let’s “wow” your friends on social media with something amazing!

How do I place an order?

The first step to ordering a custom cake is to through a quick cake consultation. You can call us, email, or contact us on social media. Here are a few things we need to know:

  • What is your event?
  • When is your event?
  • How many people would you like to feed?
  • Do you have a theme, colors, design ideas?

We always recommend grabbing a few pictures of your theme, idea, or another cake you like online and we’ll work with you to create a unique design catered to your event.

How much is a custom cake?

We cannot quote a price until we know exactly what you need. Custom cake prices depend on the number of people you would like to feed and the complexity of the design. We can tell you that custom cakes start at $75 and prices move into the $300 to $500 range depending on what you want.
Remember, our cakes are works of art designed to “drop a few jaws” and “wow” your guests, so you will pay a premium price. However, we can work within your budget and play with the design and offer other options, such as a smaller cake with other desserts to meet your needs. Just give us a call and we’ll work with you.

When do I pay?

A deposit of 50% of your total price is required to book a cake order. The remaining balance is due on the day of your event (but can be paid any time before). If your cake is being delivered, the balance is due before the cake is delivered.

Can I cancel my cake?

All cake deposits are non-refundable. Cancellations must be made a week prior to your event date in order to be refunded the final 50% of the order. Cakes can be rescheduled or pushed to a later date if we are given at least one week’s notice.

Custom Cakes Gallery

(Wedding, Birthday, Disney, Cupcakes)

Cake Consultations

Ordering a custom cake is simple and can be done in a number of ways:

  1. Pick up the phone and give us a call. We’ll walk you through the details.
  2. Contact us through social media.
  3. Fill out our cake consultations form below and one of our designers will get back to you within one business day.
  4. Come into our shop for a FREE in-store consultation

Here are a few things to think about before filling out the consultation form:

  • Date, time and location of your event
  • Number of people you will need to feed
  • Event theme, colors, design ideas
Invalid Email